These days I am again a teacher of a teacher. I am working with a bright and thoughtful young woman who would like to teach high school English. Each time I do this I feel like I am learning more than I am teaching. It's a wonderful opportunity to observe the craft of teaching and to reconsider the thousands of choices I make on a weekly basis.
Do you send out Drew because he is disrupting the class or do you try to talk him back into the class? Why isn't Alfred writing his paper? Will a pep talk help or embarass him in front of his sophomore peers whose bodies are surging beyond their control? Even if you talk out in the hall?
We have this class of sophomores right now that are dominated by bright, fun boys who totally undercut themselves because they cannot see beyond what is funny at the moment. Poor Katherine was totally deflated at the end of the day. "They hate me," she lamented. She had assigned them to write an in-class essay (the only kind you can be sure they will complete and turn in) and they complained bitterly. Two girls and a boy refused to do it. The boy has repeatedly refused to do work during the year. She sent him to an administrator. The girls sat there for a few minutes and then, seeing that they couldn't get tread, wrote the essay--with obvious contempt, but they wrote it.
As a longer-term teacher, I saw success. They were quiet, focused and did the work they were supposed to do. Katherine, who had had them excitedly whispering in her ear collaborating on an assignment the day before, thought she had again lost them. I knew they would forget over the weekend.
But it got me to thinking about this dance that teachers and students do. I am firmly in the camp that I as a teacher should help students find value in the work we do. Katherine does as well. We try hard to help them see the value of understanding how advertising and modern media manipulate them for profit and power, to understand how through language they can reassert power in their lives. There are these lucid moments of clarity where 19 students and I are one, working toward a common purpose. I'm convinced they are beginning to engage. Then, the next day I have to practically bludgeon them to write a paragraph. So, you second guess whether you have intrigued them at all. Are you giving anything of value to them?
Then, three years later, one of them will nominate you for teacher of the year or come back and thank you for teaching them how to write--tell you how what they learned in your class made college and their careers easier. I promised Katherine one day that would come. In the meantime, she will have to trust herself.